The Tax Man Cometh
Today my business was audited by the IRS.
Of course it was absolutely absurd for the IRS to spend money on auditing tiny little excruciatingly honest me.
And it was fascinating.
To start with, the IRS man, who, since I didn’t ask permission, I’ll just call by his first initial – “M” – was very nice. Not that I expected otherwise, but it was delightful to go through the process with someone who was just genuinely nice and whom I could enjoy talking and even laughing with.
And the whole thing took about 1/3 the time he’d told me to expect.
Why? Very simple: I have very complete, very organized records.
My being organized is slightly legendary among friends and acquaintances. I’ve been called everything from anal to self-disciplined. I don’t think the former is true, and the latter is definitely not.
You see, I have an absolute hatred for not being able to find things. Therefore, it’s pretty much impossible for me to create piles of stuff, or to not file things, or even to not balance my checking accounts. It would, weirdly enough, be far more of an effort of self-discipline for me to not be organized.
This meant that, following the instructions in the letter I received from M, I spent about two hours over the weekend collecting file folders and printing out the electronic receipts for Internet purchases I’d made that year.
When he arrived, it was all laid out on my dining room table. He spent about 45 minutes interviewing me about my business and my records, and then I turned him loose on the folders and went back to work.
And because it was all so organized, and because everything on one side of the picture (deposits to my business and personal accounts) had an origin on the other side of the picture (business income, for instance), he was done by noon.
Initially, it seemed that my tax software had barfed and created an error in the IRS’s favour.
But then we spent an additional half hour tracking down an apparent discrepancy, and discovered that the barfing was actually in my favor.
To cut a rapidly-growing-too-long story short, here’s what I learned that might help you in your IRS travels, whether you have a business of your own or not.
- Keep those records. Even if for you it is a matter of self-discipline, it’s so worth it. M told me that most audits take at least a day, usually a day and a half or more. And if your records are wonky, not only will it be a more-painful audit process, but you’ll just generally have a greater chance of missed deductions and other errors. All of which will have to be sorted out in an audit, and which may be costing you real money every year.
- Don’t panic. These guys aren’t here to catch you doing something wrong. They really are – or at least, M certainly was – just interested in ensuring accuracy.
- Be aware of what might flag an audit. In my case, it was three things – and I’d do them all exactly the same again, with the possible exception of the error made by my tax software!
- This was an audit of an early year in my business, and one of their questions was, quite reasonably, “How is she paying her bills?” (A question I wondered about myself that year…)
- The deduction for utilities was disproportionately high versus known utility rates, what would be expected for a utility bill for a home office, and what I’d reported the previous year. (This is where my tax software goofed.)
- Similarly, my health insurance premiums were disproportionate to what I’d reported the previous year. (That was easy; I’d for some reason not reported any the previous year, even though I’d had insurance.)
- Be aware that your tax software (if you use software) or even your paid tax preparer person (if that’s how you get your taxes done) can goof. That’s what happened to what was reported for my utility bills. I’m not at all sure what I’d do differently, because I rather doubt I’d have caught the errors that were made… but I do plan to review the final filing a little more carefully now I know what can happen.
Even though you may be running a very small, not to say itty-bitty, business, the tax man is watching. So if you don’t know how to keep accurate records, get help. (I owe my friend Sherry a HUGE vote of thanks for her help getting my bookkeeping process established early on in my business!)
And if you do get picked for an audit, don’t panic. Making it easy for them will help them make it easy for you.
Me? I not only have a whole unexpected half day today to catch up on work I’d expected to be doing tomorrow, but it also looks like I’ll probably be getting a very small check from the IRS. (Very small. But better that, than t’other way around!)
Posted: December 7th, 2009 under Small business.
Comments
Comment from
Grace
Time December 7, 2009 at 9:42 pm
Mark – Yes, indeed.
I made a comment something along those lines to “M,” my auditor, and he gave me a bit of a funny look and said, “Be careful what you wish for.”
Just ’cause the first one went well doesn’t always mean the next one will be as happy.
Still, as my finance guy says, tax avoidance is legal; it’s tax evasion that gets you in trouble!
Comment from
Margaret Lukens
Time December 8, 2009 at 4:58 pm
I have an audit scheduled for this Thursday. Pulling together all the documents the IRS auditor has requested makes me doubly glad I’m a professional organizer. Receipts for 2007? Not a problem!
I hope my audit goes as smoothly as yours did, Grace.
Comment from
Grace
Time December 8, 2009 at 5:08 pm
Margaret – Yes, I totally get what you’re saying! It’s so cool to just be able to go to the file cabinet and put my hand on exactly what I want.
That’s why I say I can’t not be organized – it’s just how I’m hooked up.
GOOD LUCK with your audit! check back and let us know how it goes!
Comment from
FreeTaxUSA
Time December 9, 2009 at 10:21 am
Great advice on reducing the stress of an audit. Just out of curiosity, how many years back did they go for the audit?
It looks like audits are increasing on all tax payers (regardless of income level or tax situation). This IRS article is from the 2007 year but I’m sure the trend is the same for the 2008 tax year.
Comment from
Grace
Time December 11, 2009 at 9:33 am
FreeTaxUSA – How funny to see the numbers in that article about increases in audits of people with incomes over $1million and over $200,000.
They left out the statistics on people making less than that; I would be very curious to know what those increases were.
Yes, it was for the 2007 tax year.

I will be eternally grateful for your great gift of taking in to the fullest extent what it is that I
have to offer, living it, and then reflecting it back in terms of the potential experience of others.
You have given words to a process that defies words. And you’re constantly in a position to help
me continue to hone that, deeper and deeper and more and more resonantly, who I am and what I offer,
which is truly invaluable. — Jon Hansen,
What you’ve sent me is so darn perfect it hurts! It’s a sheer pleasure to work with someone
who writes as beautifully as you do — and in “my” voice. — Ariane Goodwin, Ed.D,
You have a real gift for words. You’re really, really good at it. — Sherry Essig,


Comment from Mark W Schumann
Time December 7, 2009 at 9:28 pm
My father keeps records in a far less organized manner, and he got audited quite a few years ago now.
After spending all day with the IRS examiner, he was told to wait for the audit results. A month or two later, the letter came back indicating errors had been found in the government’s favor, so enclosed please find a check for something like $900.
A while later, another letter came, explaining that the first letter had been in error. Along with a check for an additional $1200.
Dad says he would welcome another tax audit at the government’s convenience.
Mark W Schumann´s last blog ..When your C# has to be fast.